On The Reel Charters Customer Reviews

Name: On The Reel Charters
Brand: On The Reel Charters
Rating: 5 (11 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 11
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Rich delivers exceptional fishing results that keep customers coming back for more. His dedication to ensuring clients catch fish shows through impressive trips where anglers land multiple species in a single outing. Recent charters have produced excellent catches including Mahi, Tuna, and Grouper, demonstrating his ability to locate productive fishing spots and guide customers to success. Customers consistently praise Richard's commitment to going above and beyond their expectations. His amazing approach to guiding creates memorable experiences that exceed what most anglers hope for on their fishing adventures. The combination of his expertise and dedication results in trips that customers enthusiastically recommend to other fishing enthusiasts.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Catching Fish

Above And Beyond

Amazing Captain

Mahi Tuna Grouper

Highly Recommend

Exceptional Results

Productive Spots

Memorable Experiences

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Fish lying in white cooler box on boat deck

Fresh caught fish displayed on ice in cooler after successful fishing trip

Fresh caught fish displayed on wooden surface outdoors

Three fresh caught tuna fish displayed on fishing boat deck over ocean waters

Fresh caught fish including mahi mahi, red grouper, cero mackerel, and blackfin tuna displayed on boat cleaning table

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Jake Shephard

April 7, 2026

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada, FL - Cobia, Amberjack And More on April 7, 2026

8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Great day of fishing with Rich. My wife and I took our 2 teenage kids on a 4 hour trip. Rich worked super hard to find some fish on a slow day. We ended up catching our fill of blackfin tuna. Awesome! Highly recommend booking a charter with Rich.

Was this helpful ?

Natalia P

February 10, 2026

Trip - Extended Guided Fishing And Sand Bar Trip In Islamorada - Marlin, Cobia And More on February 10, 2026

8:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Girls’ trip + Marco Island fishing = SUCCESS thanks to Captain Rich! We were beginners and he made us feel like pros. Great energy, super helpful, and we caught so many fish. 10/10 !! By the end, we were pleasantly exhausted—in the best way—from the sun and a full day on the water, and we couldn’t stop talking about how much fun we had. Captain Rich was professional, safe, and genuinely fun to be around. We’d absolutely book again—highly recommend!

Was this helpful ?

Sean Fortune

February 8, 2026

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada, FL - Cobia, Amberjack And More on February 8, 2026

8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Definitely one of the most fun fishing experiences I have had. Thanks Captain Richie your passion for the water is unmatched, see you on the next run!!!!!!!

Was this helpful ?

Jon Parrish

January 16, 2026

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada, FL - Cobia, Amberjack And More on January 16, 2026

8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Full-day trip in Key Largo and it was absolutely worth it. We went pretty far offshore, and the weather was chilly—we were definitely cold at times. Even so, the captain and mate worked hard the entire time—moving when needed, switching techniques, and keeping us fishing nonstop. We covered a lot of water and stayed focused on finding action. We ended up putting fish in the boat (mahi, barracuda, and most importantly, tuna!) and learned a ton along the way. Professional, friendly crew and a great experience—would book again.

Was this helpful ?

Alec R

November 17, 2025

Trip - on November 17, 2025

We had a great time fishing, even if the fish didn’t quite get the memo. The captain and mate worked hard all day. We fished for eight hours, covered a lot of water, and worked the entire water column, from the surface down to about 400 feet. We tried just about everything, including trolling, jigging, sight casting, live bait, and deep drop setups. We did manage to land a few mahi, some barracuda, and a couple of small tuna. Some days are just like that, but the effort and attitude made the trip worthwhile. I’ll definitely be back to give it another shot.

Was this helpful ?

Ethan Santos

July 9, 2025

Trip - Half Day Sandbar Fun And Sun Cruise In Islamorada on July 9, 2025

8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Great captain caught many fish captain and first mate funny and great guys

Was this helpful ?

Hudson Mccain

June 18, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada, FL - Cobia, Amberjack And More on June 18, 2025

8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Great captain and first mate, both knew exactly what they were doing and got us tons of fish. Awesome boat as well

Was this helpful ?

Hayden McCain

June 18, 2025

Trip - Half Day Guided Fishing Trip In Islamorada, FL - Cobia, Amberjack And More on June 18, 2025

8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

Had an amazing trip with on the reel. First mate and captain were both extremely personal and professional. Had lots of bad luck and bad charters everywhere else in the keys but on the reel did an amazing job. We limited out on tuna and caught plenty of mahi and grouper to throw in the fridge. Richie and Wyatt know exactly what they are doing and we definitely will not be going back to anyone else. Thank you fellas!

Was this helpful ?

Chris M

May 28, 2025

Trip - on May 28, 2025

My family has done four charters in Key Largo over the past few years, and all of them were a complete bust. On The Reel finally put us on productive spots, and we caught enough fish to eat for days.

Was this helpful ?

Krista G

August 9, 2024

Trip - on August 9, 2024

We were focused on catching fish, and Captain Rich went above and beyond to ensure we did. Highly recommend him!

Was this helpful ?

Armando C

June 16, 2024

Trip - on June 16, 2024

The captain was amazing, and we ended up catching Mahi, Tuna, and Grouper all in one trip!

Was this helpful ?

Experience Thrilling Charters in Beautiful Islamorada!

About On The Reel Charters Business Reviews

The customer reviews page for On The Reel Charters is where satisfied anglers share their incredible experiences fishing in Islamorada. Visitors can read firsthand accounts of thrilling Islamorada fishing charters, highlighting successful catches and memorable moments on the water. Guests often rave about the expertise of Captain Richard, whether during deep sea fishing Islamorada adventures or relaxed family fishing charters Islamorada. Reviews frequently mention the pristine beauty of the Florida Keys, whether enjoyed through snapper fishing charters Islamorada or serene Islamorada sandbar tours. Many customers praise the professional service, well-equipped boat, and diverse trip options like offshore fishing Islamorada and eco fishing tours Islamorada. Families, avid anglers, and first-timers alike leave glowing feedback, emphasizing the fun and excitement of their outings. The page is a testament to the unforgettable fishing trips and quality service that On The Reel Charters provides.

On The Reel Charters Customer Reviews are provided by our guests. We focus on providing our Islamorada Fishing Charter guests the very best experience. Our Fishing reviews are from trips in Atlantic Ocean.